Das zufriedene Schwein. Utilitarianism (John Stuart Mill) [The Satisfied Pig. Utilitarianism (John Stuart Mill)]

Abstract

Christian Seidel reconstructs Mill’s comparison between the satisfied pig and the dissatisfied human as the conclusion of an argument that incorporates central components of the so-called “qualitative hedonism.” The example rhetorically condenses Mill’s new theoretical framework, illustrates a conceptual distinction between satisfaction and happiness, and serves dialectically both as a response to a concern about Mill’s decided preference criterion and as a defense against the contemporary charge of pig philosophy.

Published
Illustrieren, prüfen, begründen? Über die Rolle von Beispielen in der Praktischen Philosophie von Aristoteles bis Rawls [Illustrating, Examining, Justifying? On the Role of Examples in Practical Philosophy from Aristotle to Rawls]. Ed. by Karoline Reinhardt, Gottfried Schweiger, & Johanna Sinn. Bielefeld: transcript, p. 151–174